Peter, Lily and the Nose: compositing tests

This week I have started filming some scenes for my animation, and working with shadow-puppets it is the shortest part of the whole process for me, most of the time consuming work is making the puppets and trying to work out what they'll need to do and making different replacement hands and faces, and it's weird to realise after filming a scene that it took two or three days to cut out and design, but only maybe 30 minutes to film and then it's finished with.  I'm trying to do only one or two takes for each scene, I want it to feel spontaneous and not too laboured over.   When I read about other people making animation I get the feeling that we are all making it up as we go along - the process is old and simple, but you have to concentrate totally and react to how the puppets are moving and respond and make changes on the spot, and it's different for every film, sometimes every scene, the puppets don;t always move the way you imagined.

In this film I'm building up layers of animations to create the scenes - and here is an example I've roughly composited to see if it's working okay . . . I'll show you the process, starting with the first take, which I had to abandon as soon as I watched the playback, as the puppet already wasn't working very well - you can have a look here, Lily, the main girl character is slipping around on the motorbike . .

I thought it would give her character a dangerous vitality if she wasn't fixed down, but it just looked weird and floaty . . . so I added a pivot point to her bottom and I think it gives her a better sense of weight.  I layered this video with a pencil animation of the rain (which i posted earlier this year if you want to have a look) and an animated continuously moving cityscape background, the buildings were made in a loop so I could animate it for as long as i needed instead of just looping the footage like I did with the rain:

Here is the scene with all three parts layered together: